smartproxy/implementation-summary.md

SmartProxy ACME Simplification Implementation Summary

Overview

We successfully implemented comprehensive support for both global and route-level ACME configuration in SmartProxy v19.0.0, addressing the certificate acquisition issues and improving the developer experience.

What Was Implemented

1. Enhanced Configuration Support

• Added global ACME configuration at the SmartProxy level
• Maintained support for route-level ACME configuration
• Implemented configuration hierarchy where global settings serve as defaults
• Route-level settings override global defaults when specified

2. Updated Core Components

SmartProxy Class (smart-proxy.ts)

• Enhanced ACME configuration normalization in constructor
• Added support for both email and accountEmail fields
• Updated initializeCertificateManager to prioritize configurations correctly
• Added validateAcmeConfiguration method for comprehensive validation

SmartCertManager Class (certificate-manager.ts)

• Added globalAcmeDefaults property to store top-level configuration
• Implemented setGlobalAcmeDefaults method
• Updated provisionAcmeCertificate to use global defaults
• Enhanced error messages to guide users to correct configuration

ISmartProxyOptions Interface (interfaces.ts)

• Added comprehensive documentation for global ACME configuration
• Enhanced IAcmeOptions interface with better field descriptions
• Added example usage in JSDoc comments

3. Configuration Validation

• Checks for missing ACME email configuration
• Validates port 80 availability for HTTP-01 challenges
• Warns about wildcard domains with auto certificates
• Detects environment mismatches between global and route configs

4. Test Coverage

Created comprehensive test suite (test.acme-configuration.node.ts):

• Top-level ACME configuration
• Route-level ACME configuration
• Mixed configuration with overrides
• Error handling for missing email
• Support for accountEmail alias

5. Documentation Updates

Main README (readme.md)

• Added global ACME configuration example
• Updated code examples to show both configuration styles
• Added dedicated ACME configuration section

Certificate Management Guide (certificate-management.md)

• Updated for v19.0.0 changes
• Added configuration hierarchy explanation
• Included troubleshooting section
• Added migration guide from v18

Readme Hints (readme.hints.md)

• Added breaking change warning for ACME configuration
• Included correct configuration example
• Added migration considerations

Key Benefits

1. Reduced Configuration Duplication: Global ACME settings eliminate need to repeat configuration
2. Better Developer Experience: Clear error messages guide users to correct configuration
3. Backward Compatibility: Route-level configuration still works as before
4. Flexible Configuration: Can mix global defaults with route-specific overrides
5. Improved Validation: Warns about common configuration issues

Testing Results

All tests pass successfully:

• Global ACME configuration works correctly
• Route-level configuration continues to function
• Configuration hierarchy behaves as expected
• Error messages provide clear guidance

Migration Path

For users upgrading from v18:

1. Existing route-level ACME configuration continues to work
2. Can optionally move common settings to global level
3. Route-specific overrides remain available
4. No breaking changes for existing configurations

Conclusion

The implementation successfully addresses the original issue where SmartAcme was not initialized due to missing configuration. Users now have flexible options for configuring ACME, with clear error messages and comprehensive documentation to guide them.